Wholly Ourselves
Hosted by Josh Proctor, this podcast invites you to explore the richness and complexity of our identities, especially where sexuality and faith converge. We explore how the Gospel speaks to every part of who we are, across queer and straight experiences alike. This is a space for questions, transformation, and belonging.
Episodes

7 days ago
7 days ago
1 hr 15 min
In this episode, I sit down with Greg Coles and Julia Hejduk, the co-authors of Sexuality Beyond Sex: Unexpected Conversations on Embodiment, Identity, and Desire, to talk about what it means to be a sexual person beyond having sex. We explore how our culture and our churches have made an idol of sex and marriage, why it matters to see ourselves as betrothed rather than deprived, and how the Song of Songs, our longings, and even the Eucharist can point us toward our ultimate union with God. The book is out now.
Order Sexuality Beyond Sex Now!
Preorder Becoming Wholly Ourselves (coming out June 8th): https://shorturl.at/Cg5FN
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Oct 28, 2026
Oct 28, 2026
1 hr 16 min
In this episode, I sit down with my dear friend Remi, the new host of Life on Side B, to talk about the current state of trans inclusion in the Side B community, from the fracturing we’re seeing to why so many conversations about trans people are happening without trans people in the room. We dig into why a Side B sexual ethic can’t simply be copied and pasted onto the trans experience, the “LGB without the T” narrative that erases trans leadership in queer history, and how gay men’s internalized homophobia and discomfort with femininity can fuel transphobia. Along the way, we talk about healing and minority fatigue, and Remi shares a sneak peek at what’s coming in the new season of Life on Side B.
Preorder Becoming Wholly Ourselves (coming out June 8th): https://shorturl.at/Cg5FN
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Oct 7, 2026
Oct 7, 2026
1 hr 9 sec
In this episode, I sit down with my friends Brian Nietzel and Barnabas Lin, whom I met through Oriented to Love, to talk about our journeys with faith, sexuality, and church. We discuss why "sides" can be a helpful starting language but become a problem when they harden into boxes, and what it looks like to trust one another's sacred conclusions while still asking thoughtful questions. Along the way, we share what we wish other queer Christians understood about our experiences, and where you can find Brian's work with Making Things Right and Barnabas's upcoming book, Christianity Is Dying a Bible Verse at a Time.
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Preorder Becoming Wholly Ourselves (coming out June 8th)
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Aug 24, 2026
Aug 24, 2026
1 hr 9 min
Keith Wildenberg, co-founder of Building Catholic Futures, comes on the podcast to discuss some of the frameworks of faith and formation that Build Catholic Futures is developing in their work to support the faith of LGBTQ Catholics.
Check out their work at https://buildingcatholic.org/
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Jul 20, 2026
Jul 20, 2026
57 min
Ashley Murphy, the youth director on staff with Josh, joins him on the podcast to talk about lessons from ministry on caring for the least of these.
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Jul 6, 2026
Jul 6, 2026
28 min
Josh shares a recent sermon from Pentecost, analyzing the parable of the generous landowner and what it teaches about inclusion in the church.
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Jun 22, 2026
Jun 22, 2026
1 hr 9 min
Meg Baatz — the OG guest of Life on Side B and co-founder of Kaleidoscope — joins Josh to talk leadership in faith and sexuality spaces. Fresh off stepping away from her role at Kaleidoscope, Meg unpacks the real difference between influence and leadership, why trust in pastors and institutions has collapsed across generations, and what integrity looks like when your public and private life are on the line. They close with advice for anyone desiring to lead as well as those let down by a spiritual leader.
Subscribe Meg Baatz's Substack to follow her journey going forward: https://substack.com/@megbaatz
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

Jun 8, 2026
Jun 8, 2026
59 min
It's Pride Month! Rachel and Josh sit down for a discussion about Pride Month, its origins, their evolving relationships with the celebrations, and the reaction of Christians to the month.
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

May 25, 2026
May 25, 2026
1 hr 53 sec
Rachel and Josh talk about purity culture, where it comes from, the ways it impacted them differently and the residual effects of it in our world today.
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends

May 11, 2026
May 11, 2026
57 min
Josh sits down with Dr. Beth, spiritual director and teacher at Kairos University, to explore spiritual direction. Together they unpack what spiritual direction actually is, how it differs from therapy and pastoral care, and why creating sacred space for God to speak is more powerful than any advice or answer a director could give. Whether you're curious about finding a spiritual director or considering becoming one yourself, this conversation will leave you with a deeper understanding of what it means to slow down, release control, and trust the Spirit.
Become a Patron: https://patreon.com/whollyourselves
Subscribe to Josh's Monthly Substack: https://whollyourselves.org/#substack
Ask a question or send a message: https://www.whollyourselves.org/podcast
Credit: Our Theme Song is "Leave it All Behind" by The Transient Friends






